Search
Search every published claim, filter by topic and by finding, or browse the whole record below.
Every checked claim
Grouped by topic. A claim with more than one topic is filed under its first, so the counts add up. A claim that is not here may be under a question we parked or declined, or a finding we have taken off the board, and either way the reason is with it.
20 claims under 9 questions: 5 Supported · 7 Partially supported · 4 Not established · 4 Contradicted
Transportation
Did the committee cut bike-lane speakers from five minutes to three, with about 70 waiting to speak?
Supported
Yes. Edmonton's Infrastructure Committee cut speakers' time limit from five minutes to three, when 64 entries were listed to speak on the bike lanes, though the 52 recorded as speaking fall short of about seventy.
What the records show about Edmonton's August 2026 bike-lane hearing · VerifiedPartially supported
Partly. Council's Infrastructure Committee neither adopted nor voted down administration's plan for 14 bike routes, and full Council had not decided it by September 25 in the records the reviewers read.
Edmonton's bike routes and the August 2026 committee vote · VerifiedDid Edmonton's administration recommend freezing 14 future bike routes to reassess them?
Partially supported
Partly. Administration's original plan would have taken 14 bike routes out of the program for 2026 and 2027, but its latest only set them aside without saying they would wait. Its middle version held them back too.
Edmonton's bike routes and the August 2026 committee vote · VerifiedPartially supported
Partly. Councillors Karen Principe and Jennifer Rice brought two cuts to Edmonton's bike-lane budget and council voted both down, but only one would have left about $50 million.
Edmonton's bike routes and the August 2026 committee vote · VerifiedSupported
Yes. Counting a proposal once it is on a published agenda, administration had at least two snow proposals seeking more money before council or a committee by August 27, 2026, and we found three. None of them states the snow budget it would add to, so on a stricter reading that requires the snow budget each would add to, none would count, and if the comment meant precisely two, it is partly right.
What the records show about Edmonton's snow clearing and its costs · VerifiedWere Edmonton's roads in poor condition in the City's latest published ratings?
Partially supported
Partly. The City's latest ratings put about a ninth of Edmonton's roads in poor or very poor condition at the end of 2024, counting them by what they would cost to replace.
Is Edmonton letting roads go while funding bike lanes? · VerifiedPartially supportedSplit panel
Partly. The City's budget lists all $100 million as general borrowing that road or alley renewal could have used, but one of the three AI reviewers could not open that budget to check.
Is Edmonton letting roads go while funding bike lanes? · VerifiedPartially supported
Partly. The $100 million came to about a fifteenth of the renewal the City said it could not fund from 2023 to 2026, too much to dismiss and far short of a serious share.
Is Edmonton letting roads go while funding bike lanes? · VerifiedHas the City taken driving lanes for bike lanes all over Edmonton?
Not established
Nobody can tell from the records. Edmonton did take driving lanes for bike lanes on some streets, but the records we found cannot show whether it happened all over the city.
Bike lanes and Edmonton traffic · VerifiedPartially supportedSplit panel
Partly. Two of the three reviewers found about 1.29 million bicycle counts in the City of Edmonton's own data for January to July 2026, and the third could not confirm the City had published all seven months.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDo the Edmonton bike lanes the City meters carry little or no bicycle traffic?
ContradictedAdjacent panel
No. The City recorded a median of at least 46 bicycles a day at every one of the 20 counters that sat on Edmonton's on-street bike lanes and ran through July 2025.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDo only about 1 to 2 percent of Edmonton's population ride a bicycle?
Not established
Nobody can tell from the published record. No representative survey of Edmontonians has published how many of them ride a bicycle.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDo only 1 percent of Edmontonians ride year-round, and fewer than 15 percent the rest of the year?
Not established
Nobody can tell. No representative survey of Edmonton residents has published how many ride through the winter and how many ride the rest of the year.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedAre about 2 percent of all trips in Edmonton made by bicycle?
Supported
Yes, roughly. Edmonton residents made 1.7 per cent of their weekday trips by bicycle in the City's 2015 travel survey, which is the most recent one published.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDo fewer than 1 percent of Edmonton commuters travel to work by bicycle?
Supported
Yes. Statistics Canada found that fewer than one in 100 Edmonton commuters used a bicycle as their main way of getting to work in the 2021 census.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDo 87 percent of Edmontonians commute by car?
Supported
Yes, near enough. Statistics Canada recorded 85 per cent of Edmonton commuters travelling by car, truck or van in the 2021 census.
How much Edmonton cycles · VerifiedDid Edmonton lose $82 million on its electric buses?
Not established
Nobody can tell yet. Edmonton filed an $82 million claim in Proterra's bankruptcy, but that does not show whether the city lost $82 million on its electric buses.
What happened with Edmonton's electric buses? · VerifiedDo Edmonton's problems with Proterra buses prove that electric buses don't work in cold cities?
Contradicted
No. Toronto's transit agency reviewed its own electric buses and found no fundamental technology barrier, so one failed Edmonton contract does not settle it for cold cities.
What happened with Edmonton's electric buses? · VerifiedDoes Edmonton's winter make cycling unworkable as a serious way of getting around?
Contradicted
No. People in the Oulu region of northern Finland make about one trip in ten by bicycle in winter, so Edmonton's cold weather alone cannot make cycling unworkable.
Is Edmonton too cold for cycling to work? · Verified
Growth & planning
Contradicted
No. Council voted 12 to 0 to add a line to the District Policy saying that neither it nor the district plans may restrict freedom of movement.
Do Edmonton's 15-minute districts limit where people can travel? · Verified